Within Limits

Written by

in

The Blanks

Nine years on the bench at the Bracker water plant, and I had grown colonies exactly once before — a heat wave July in ’86, when the incubator ran hot and the state threw out the whole month for every system east of Columbus. After that, clean. Monday runs, five routine samples, membrane filtration, twenty-four hours at thirty-five degrees, and the little grid squares come up empty and you write absent five times in blue and mail it in with the chlorine numbers. Two wells, nineteen hundred customers, one lab, one me.

The third Monday in June, sample four grew.

Eleven colonies, sheen and spread, the kind you can count without the scope. Total coliform. I ran it twice from the same filtrate before I called anybody, and it grew twice, and then I stood in the door of the supply room for a while with my coffee, doing the arithmetic a lab person does. A hit means notice to the state within twenty-four hours. Repeat samples, five of them, plus upstream, plus triggered source monitoring on both wells. It means the village letter goes out and the booster club cancels the concession stand, and it goes on the plant’s record next to my name, because in Bracker the analyst and the record are the same person.

Walt Sipe had four months left before retirement. He stood at my shoulder with his glasses pushed up into the gray of his hair and read the grid through the plastic and asked the first question the way you’d ask a grandkid.

“Check your blanks?”

I had. Sterile water, sterile saline, both clean, all of it clean. But I’d run short of buffered dilution water the week before and finished the set with a bottle borrowed from the county van, and a borrowed bottle is a story. It’s a small story. It fits on one page.

MEMO TO FILE — 6/19/95. Routine sample #4, positive for total coliform (11 colonies). Investigation: possible contamination of dilution water borrowed from county supply during week of 6/12. Blanks sterile. Resample taken 6/20 per standard procedure. — D. Marn, Operator-Analyst II

The resample ran absent. All of it. The memo went in the binder, the binder went on the shelf, and June closed out clean, and I want to be honest about the order those things happened in, because I think the order matters now. The resample came back first. The memo explained it second. I had the answer before I had the reason, and I reached into the week and picked out the one thing that would hold it.

I wanted it to be the lab. That’s the whole of it. Nobody ordered anything.

Flush Longer

August is the lead and copper round. First-draw, one liter, the tap sitting six hours untouched, and you take the customer’s kitchen at seven in the morning because that’s the rule and the rule is the sample. Delancey Street, Mrs. Kubiak’s kitchen, the cold tap with the green glass knob. The DR/2000 read out 0.018.

The action level is 0.015.

Walt didn’t come look at the digits. He sat at his desk with the retirement paperwork fanned out and asked about the aerator, and how long the line sat, and whether Mrs. Kubiak had plumbing work done lately, and he was right about all of it being worth asking — that’s the terrible part, every question he asked was a real question with a real answer somewhere in it. Her nephew had swapped the angle stop in April. There was a little bag of parts and a receipt to prove it.

NOTATION, 8/2/95 — Lead/copper tap #3: recent private plumbing repair at residence (April). Sample retaken 8/9 following consultation. Result 0.011 mg/L. System 90th percentile 0.009 — in compliance.

The number was the number. It came up on the readout in green and I wrote it down, and the round passed, and the ninety-fifth percentile wasn’t anywhere near the line, and somewhere in the same week I stopped filling the kettle at the plant tap. Not deciding to. Coffee at the bench had tasted of coins off and on since spring, and one morning I was carrying the pot to the sink and my arm just took it to the utility sink in the washroom instead, the one plumbed to the well by the road, and after that I let it.

The creek below the outfall ran clear all August, which is what creeks do when nothing lives in them. The minnows had gone out of the riffle by the county road sometime that spring. Dogs on River Road learned to wait at their doors until someone filled their bowls from the house.

The Smooth Pen

The residual recorder is a drum chart, one revolution a week, and the pen arm has a hitch in it that I have nursed with a spirit level and a razor blade since before Walt’s first retirement announcement. When the feed pump surges, the pen chatters. It chattered at 3:10 on a Thursday in September while I stood in front of it with my hand on the chemical room door, because I had heard the pump kick twice and come down to look.

The strip for that week came off the drum smooth as a sermon. Textbook curve, the kind they photocopy for the training manuals. I lined the drum mark up with my log entry and the two disagreed, and the chart is the legal record and my log is a notebook.

So I ran a test that wasn’t a compliance sample, because compliance samples get signed. I spiked a sterile blank with standard enough to fail anything in the state, labeled it S-1 in grease pencil so I’d know it, and put it through the DR/2000.

0.015.

Exactly. Then again, fresh standard, fresh blank, S-2: 0.015. Instruments drift. Instruments flatter nobody. Two decimals of exactly-at-the-line, twice, is not chemistry; it’s a clerk counting the till and reporting what the house needs.

I split a raw sample with Lu Trevino at the Marta County lab, off the books, friend to friend. Her results came back Thursday and mine were decimal-identical to hers — not close, identical, the same digit in the last place, and Lu’s lab and mine have never agreed on the last place in eleven years of side-by-splits at the operators’ school.

I stopped sending her anything after that. There’s no percentage in teaching it new friends.

Survey Week

The inspector was young, a kid named Prosser with a state jacket two sizes big, and he did it all by the book: walked the wells, checked the hypo feed, then sat at my bench with five years of binders, which the rules make me keep, and read.

The binders read clean. All of them, all the way back — June’s fourth sample absent in my own blue ink on my own numbered sheet, Delancey 0.011, every grid and every readout exactly what the village needed, and the handwriting mine, and the ink the right age. The spiral notebook I keep for the ugly first numbers — mine too. Clean, in my hand. A record doesn’t have to change in front of you. It just has to have always been what it now is.

He shook my hand at the door of the plant and said it was the cleanest paperwork he’d seen in the county, and left a card, and said if anything ever doesn’t look right, call first, we like to keep it informal.

The creek jar rode my dashboard through all of it. Water from the dead riffle, lid on tight, dated on masking tape. It’s the one sample in Bracker that never went through the lab.

Here is what handing it over buys. A rush order comes back fine — or it comes back bad, and then the state wants the bench sheets it came from, and the bench sheets are mine, five years of them, smooth in my own hand, and there is not one page in that room that can say the instruments learned. The page for that doesn’t exist. The only falsifier these binders can describe is me.

Walt retired on a Friday. The board signed me superintendent in November and the county paper ran my picture under the headline about the tie-in grant.

The kitchen at home got a bottled cooler that fall, five-gallon jugs on the porch every other Thursday, no explanation offered to my daughter beyond the tap water tastes flat, doesn’t it. The jar lives in the fridge door now. The tape went brittle and the date ran off it, so it’s just a jar, and that’s fitting — it couldn’t be submitted anywhere anyway. My fingertips prickle on cold mornings, on and off, both hands. The clinic in Reedsville sends blood to a reference lab, and I’ve seen where reference labs get their water.

Every morning I initial the plant log.

The pen doesn’t skip.