The Fourth Chair

Written by

in

The Empty Place

My mother set five places for four people at every meal of her life. Papa, my brother Vern, me, herself — and one more, down at the end near the window, with the good fork. Ask her about it and she’d say, “In case.” In case of what took forty years of asking and got nobody anywhere, so eventually the family stopped asking. Casseroles, threshing dinners, funeral lunches — the plate sat there through all of it. Set. Empty. Cleared.

She died in November of ’98, between harvest and hard frost, and we held Thanksgiving at my house because Papa couldn’t sit at her table. I did what she would have done: turkey, dressing, the good cloth, Vern’s kids underfoot. Somewhere between mashing the potatoes and calling everyone in, my hands set one place more than I needed. Habit. Grief washes dishes you don’t remember starting.

That dinner ran the way her dinners always ran. Easy. Vern and Papa got through three hours without one word about the quarter section, which had never once happened indoors. On the drive home Dean said it was the nicest meal since the funeral lunch, and I said yes, dear, and afterward I stood at the sink with the extra plate under the tap.

It had come back scraped clean. Nobody had served anything onto it.

I washed it anyway. Eleven people in my kitchen, the whipped cream going soft, and a washed plate is a washed plate.

Christmas, I set it again. I told myself it was for her.

The Year of Easy Dinners

Dean is a deacon and a practical man. In March he started giving me the look over it, and the Sunday before Easter he put the plate and the chair away in the corner cupboard while I was at church. “We’re past it now,” he said. “She’d want us past it.”

The gravy broke. The ham came out of the roaster grey at the bone. And Vern, twenty minutes in, finally mentioned the land — and by two o’clock my kitchen had heard the whole inventory: the loan Papa co-signed in ’84, the widow Hovda and the field drainage, what Vern’s wife’s family said about ours when the doors were closed, what ours said back. Dean’s mother left with her coat half on. Two grandchildren cried. Papa called Vern a word I won’t put in this book, and Vern stood up so fast his chair went over backwards.

While they yelled, I fetched the plate from the cupboard. Set it. Fork, knife, water glass. Nobody watched me do it; they were busy bleeding on each other. Inside ten minutes — I counted; that’s when the counting started — Vern picked his chair up off the floor, and then he and Papa were hugging across the corner of the table, both crying, both apologizing, and Dean’s mother stayed for pie.

The turn was too fast. Grief doesn’t turn that fast. But the pie was good, everyone went home full, I had a daughter to raise and a farm to hold in one piece, and the fourth chair stayed.

That was the year the dinners got easy, and they stayed easy. Turkey days, birthdays, harvest suppers, ordinary Tuesdays. We were known for it, in our small way. Never a cross word at that house. People said it like a compliment.

It took me years to understand what the compliment cost.

Nobody says no in my kitchen. I don’t mean we’re polite. A farm can’t afford polite — a farm runs on no: no to seed at that price, no to the co-op’s schedule, no to Gene borrowing against the baler a third time. But somewhere in those easy years the no stopped coming out of my mouth. I would open it with the whole sentence ready, the fair one, the necessary one, and what arrived instead was “Whatever you think is best,” in my own voice, warm as pie filling. Gene’s third loan: “We’ve got savings put by.” The seed contract I wanted read by a lawyer: “Sign it, then.” Every time, the words came out level and agreeable, like water finding its level, while the rest of me stood behind them holding the objection out like a dish nobody would take.

The year Jenny turned fifteen, hunting for the roll recipe, I found the back pages of Mother’s book.

1961 — never told Joe about the letter from his brother.
1972 — the money for the north forty, and where it really went.
1985 — your father and the woman at the grain office.
1997 — your turn now. You’ll understand.

Her hand, all four. Above 1961, older lines in two other hands with the ink gone brown: 1944, something about a brother and the Army; 1931, a sum of money and the single word held. Three women, one book, and every year one thing each of them never said out loud.

Peace on a farm is an expensive feed, and my family had been buying it for eighty years, plate by plate, from whatever sits at the empty place.

I could have stopped. Taken the chair out for good, read the book aloud at the table, let every word land where it was going to land. I sat with that one night, book open, kitchen dark. Papa was still living then, and gentle by then, and Jenny was fifteen and proud of our easy table, and I kept thinking about what one afternoon without the chair had done to us.

I closed the book. That is the whole of my defense.

The Co-op Parking Lot

In March of ’15 I came out of the vet’s office with a sack of cat wormer and saw Mark’s F-250 parked behind the building, in the row where nobody parks. I knew the truck. I knew the scarf hanging off the mirror, and it wasn’t Jenny’s. I sat in my own truck and did the arithmetic I didn’t need to do. Twenty minutes. Then the receptionist came out, fixed her collar in her visor mirror, and drove away. Then Mark, whistling. He waved at me like I was his favorite person alive.

Jenny got engaged that Easter. The ring is beautiful. She’s twenty-five and she beamed, and everyone at dinner beamed, and I stood up to say the thing I know — I had rehearsed it kindly, one honest sentence with the parking lot behind it — and my mouth delivered “Mark’s a good man. You’re lucky, sweetheart.” Warm as pie filling. The family toasted.

That night I wrote the letter instead. Dear Jenny. Two pages in my own hand, everything laid out fair: the parking lot, the scarf, the twenty minutes, what it meant about the boy and what it didn’t. I read it back before sealing the envelope, and the pages said, We’re so happy for you both, and you know we will love whatever family you make. My handwriting. Even, unshaken. I burned it in the sink.

An email, in October. Typed, addressed, my fingers moving under my own direction — and the screen, when I read it, said congratulations in three sentences without one hard word anywhere in it. I can compose the truth all day. I can hold the whole sentence in my head, finished, spelled. Between my head and her it turns into a blessing, every route, every road. The mouth. The hand. The keyboard.

There’s one place a cross word still goes.

The Head Table

The wedding was in June, in the church basement with the good tables. Jenny planned it herself, and at the head table she set one extra place — place card, good fork, water glass. For Grandma, she said. It’s tradition, she told her bridesmaids, so there’s never a cross word at a wedding. The girls thought that was sweet. Her cousins already set one at their own tables. It moved through the family like a recipe nobody remembers copying.

I gave the toast. I had help. I have help with all of it now — every sentence came out of me smooth and loving and exactly right, and the room laughed in the right places, and somebody’s aunt told me afterward that in thirty years she had never heard one cross word out of me about a soul.

That part is true. I checked.

Before the cake was cut, one slice was already gone. White cake, raspberry filling, nobody had served it, and the missing wedge sat in the cake like a pulled tooth. Jenny laughed and said Grandma got hers first, and everyone laughed, and I laughed too, my mouth doing it without me.

Sunday night, alone, I took Mother’s book down and wrote my line in the back, where our family keeps the things nobody can say:

2016 — Mark. Behind the vet’s, March of ’15. Ask me and I’ll tell you it’s nothing. Ask me forever; it’s what I’ll tell you.

They say I’ve never had a cross word for anyone. I haven’t. I’ve said every one of them to the chair.