The Deputy’s Rounds
Clegg gave me the pit’s rules in September 1979, walking the Nine Gates with the deputy’s stick carried between us like a tool neither of us trusted the other to hold. I was sixteen, lamped up like a Christmas tree, and no use to anybody. He was overman, forty years down, with a voice like a station tannoy in a town the trains had stopped serving.
Never whistle. Never take the last of any man’s water. Never say a pit is shut; say it’s resting. And when the top starts talking, you say it sideways.
That last one came with worked examples, drilled into me like scripture. Not the survey words, never those. You said the top’s talking. You said trouble on the top, such and such heading, send the men back to the gate. The survey words went in my report at the surface office, spelled out in my own hand whenever a spall came away, and nothing ever came of that, because the book stays up top.
I asked him why, once, filling my first report with the words sitting on the page plain as a hymn. He watched me write them and ate his snap.
“Dunno, lad. It’s just how it’s said.”
He’d had it from a man called Shotbolt, who had it from the pony men, and where the pony men got it nobody wrote down. Rules like that don’t arrive with a reason attached. They arrive with the coal face, and you carry them or you don’t.
The Allen Call
In March 1986 the top started talking in the Low Main development, and a deputy named Bramley called it in sideways, calm as Sunday. Control couldn’t read a heading out of it. The tape of that night is quoted in the inquiry report, two lines:
21:14 — trouble on the top, Low Main.
21:16 — fire crew dispatched, Low Main threes.
The trouble was in the ones. Mick Allen was setting an arch in the ones with his marrer when it went, and the fire crew stood two roadways off, propping a heading that didn’t need them.
The inquiry sat through the spring. In the autumn the cards arrived, laminated, pocket-sized, printed by the area, one for every man with a deputy’s ticket:
ROOF FALL HAZARD — SAY IT PLAIN, SAY IT WHOLE, SAY IT WHERE YOU STAND.
State district. State heading. State your position. Control dispatches on the standard wording only.
Nobody argued. The card had Mick Allen on it, in a manner of speaking. Bramley’s sideways call — Clegg’s own idiom, given calm and true — had put a crew two roadways wrong. Whatever the old rule was worth, it had not been worth anything in the Low Main.
Sideways
The falls came the way falls come after that. Not a wave of them. A run of them.
Keithy Poole was first. Card-perfect Keithy, calls given standing at the spalling itself, position stated, wording verbatim, a man the area could hold up as the new standard. Twenty-two days on, a weighting took the top out of his heading while he walked his rounds, and the survey found old workings above it, wet and unrecorded, from before the war.
Cox of the Five Feet next, then a young deputy at the Babington crosscuts, and by then I had a notebook going. Speaker, date, position stated on the call. Fall, date, position where it came down. The survey’s reason, copied out fair. Every entry consistent. Every fall sat where the survey said it would have come sooner or later anyway — wet ground, disturbed ground, the ordinary arithmetic of a hundred-year pit. And every speaker had given his position as the position of the trouble, because that was what the card asked. Say it where you stand. You stand where it’s coming.
The notebook fit the taboo and it fit the geology, the way a boot fits either foot. I could prove nothing with it, not even to myself.
Clegg’s answer was older than the cards. Say it from the gate-end. The tape doesn’t ask you to stand in the fall — the card does, but the card is a piece of laminate and can’t walk anywhere. Phone at the gate-end, wording given whole, position stated as the gate-end, which was true, that was where you stood. Then walk in with the stick and listen. By February every deputy at Harlsedge did it that way. Control got its standard phrase, and the top got it sideways, said from a roadway back, behind the line. Both satisfied, and no committee in the country could have said what, if anything, had been arranged.
In March an area man named Prudhoe sat a week with the tapes and the response logs, and found elapsed minutes lost between call and support-setting, because positions reported from gate-ends were not the positions of the hazards. His recommendation went in as a safety improvement: extension telephones at the faces, wired down the gate roads, each set’s position certified by the set itself. A call would carry its own address, and the address would be where the trouble was.
The cable went in through the spring. Clegg retired on the Friday before the extensions went live, and his last instruction to me was quiet and had no procedure number in it. “However you manage it, lad. Keep them saying it sideways.”
I signed the district compliance sheet on the Monday morning. I wanted the assistant overman’s post — surface work, days, home in time for my daughters’ teas — and you do not get days by querying a safety directive with a dead man’s idiom.
Low Hazel
The Low Hazel was new ground that autumn, low and hot, half a mile past the last of the old districts. The top started talking at half past nine on a Tuesday evening shift, and there was no reading it sideways: lids singing, dust coming off the top in little grey runs, and underneath everything a sound like somebody walking about upstairs in clogs, if the somebody weighed a hundred ton.
I walked the men out to the gate. Fourteen of them and the shot-firer, counted twice, under the steel. The gate-end phone hung on its cleat with its number painted on the box. The other phone, the new one, was at the face, four hundred yards in.
I took the stick and went back.
The rib cable ran along the side of the heading, and I kept two fingers on it the whole way, a lad at a wedding holding his mother’s arm. The top talked over my head the length of it. At the face I sounded it, and the stick came back dull, like knocking the side of a loaf. My lamp showed the card in my fist, the wording I had signed for.
I gave the call plain, and whole, and where I stood.
Roof fall hazard, Low Hazel district, Number One heading, speaking from the face.
The top came in.
The air went past my ears the wrong way. The dark filled up with more dark. My hand rode the cable home like a blind man’s dog, and I came out of the dust at the gate on my hands and knees with the stick still in my fist. Behind me the Low Hazel Number One finished itself, and there was nobody in it.
The inquiry sat in January and commended the card, the tape, the dispatcher, and me. A multiple fatality prevented by rapid standardized reporting. The area framed the minute.
My voice went after that, for three days. When it came back it came back with a hole in it. I can say the first word alone. I can say the second about leaves, about snow, about wages. Together, nothing arrives. The clinic at Mansfield wrote functional dysphonia, stress-related, common after incidents, and closed the file, and they are doctors and I am not.
The surface post came up in the spring and I got it. Days, and home for teas. I wrote the training handbook myself. Page one is the card wording, typed by me, checked by me. The book stays up top, like the reports always did. It is the laminated pocket cards that go down, one for every new lad, against the wet.
In the training room at Harlsedge a starter once asked me to say the phrase for them, so they would know how it should sound before they went down. I tried. What came out was the top’s talking, in Clegg’s old sing-song, sideways, and one transferred lad at the back nodded like something had been handed over. The rest laughed a little. I played them the tape instead. The tape says it fine, and the tape stays up top.
The cards go down with the lads. Every one of them will stand at a face sooner or later, phone in one hand, card in the other, and say it plain, and say it whole, and say it where he stands.
