The Tract Books
Every weekday for six years I rode the recorder’s elevator down at twenty past eight, before the counter opened, and put my finger on the first line of the day. That’s the job, mostly. A title searcher reads with her hands. The eye wanders — it skips lines, it loses its place by the tenth page — but a fingertip dragged down a ruled column reads every word on the page it touches, at the speed of the hand, and the hand does not lie about where it has been. By my second year I had a callus on my right index finger, a smooth plate of skin like a thimble worn on the inside, and I could tell rag paper from wood pulp in the dark. Rag paper has teeth. Pulp drags, and after 1930 the whole county drags.
The vault held the tract books back to 1834, big as cutting boards, and every parcel in Chastain County had a column in one of them. You found your parcel, you put your finger on the top line, and you walked it down: deeds, mortgages, releases, the sheriff’s sales, the odd federal tax lien, each in its own clerk’s hand, each ending with a book-and-page that moved you to the next line. Six years of that. My boss at the firm liked to say a searcher who trusted microfilm over the books was a searcher who deserved what she got, and mostly he was right, because the film for volume 214 drops two leaves and has dropped them since 1971 and nobody at the county has ever fixed it.
The county signed a scanning contract that March. They taped the notice to the counter glass:
By order of the Board of Commissioners, the vault records of the Recorder’s Office will be closed to public reference on April 16 for imaging and conversion. Thereafter, reference services will be provided by microfilm and terminal.
— Office of the Chastain County Recorder, March 1999
The firm had a closing on the Hoyle tract — forty acres, a farm pond, a buyer out of Columbus with a Friday 10 a.m. wire. The chain ran clean back to an 1837 patent except the stretch between 1911 and 1928, which lived in the bad film. So I went down every morning that April and traced the original column with my finger, the way you run a wall for termites.
The Half-Circle
On the second Tuesday my finger added something. End of the 1911 line:
1911 Jun 12 — Deed. Wm. Hoyl to Eliz. Hoyl, pt. NE¼ Sec. 14, T9N R3W. 214/519.
My hand lifted off the page, made a small half-circle in the air about a centimeter wide, and set itself down on the next line. Like brushing a crumb. Like crossing a t. I didn’t decide it; I watched it happen, the way you watch your own hand signal a turn you never meant to make.
I blamed myself, in order: coffee, sleep, the trick my wrist does when I’ve been writing my own notes too long. Old examiners keep private marks — my first boss put a dot under any recital he didn’t trust, and his boss drew a short check beside anything that had been through litigation — so half of me said habit, inherited, harmless. The other half said you have never once made that motion in your life.
Thursday it came again. Same line. Earlier — my finger was still on the H of Hoyl when the curl started, and it had a tail now, a small finish to it, the way a signature has.
The week after, earlier still. By mid-April the motion was waiting at the top of the column before my finger moved at all, the way a word waits behind your teeth. I would set my hand on the first entry and the whole shape of it would already be loaded in my tendons, a thing my hand intended that had nothing to do with me. Then the 1911 deed, and my finger rose, curved, and set down light as lifting a thread off a coat without snagging the weave.
Then it spread. The curl began marking entries it had never marked — the 1928 Wells deed, then the mineral reservation from ’49, then a 1977 mortgage that had been released the same afternoon it was taken. Always in the Hoyle column. Always in the vault. Always under a tracing finger.
I ran quiet tests. I made Dale from the abstract company trace the same column, all twenty lines, and his hand came down the page flat and dumb as a ruler. I traced a microfilm printout of the column back at the office — nothing, my finger just a finger. I put on a cotton glove and walked the original: the motion tried to come and couldn’t find me, and my hand ached afterward at the base of the thumb, a small homesick ache, a held breath let go nowhere.
Only the originals. Only the column. Only a bare hand that walks the whole column top to bottom.
The Photostat
The discard shelf stood by the loading door — books too broken to film, marked for the flatbed or the dumpster. I was avoiding my own problem the way you check the weather to avoid your mail, and I pulled down a 1921 photostat abstract somebody had compiled on the Hoyl chain.
The margin note sat beside the 1911 entry. Iron-gall ink gone tea-colored, a half-circle with a tail, and under it, initials: W.J.M.
Not a print artifact. Not a stain. The same stroke, with the same little finish, made by a hand that held a pen instead of tracing a column. I checked the staff ledgers that evening — the county kept them, every recorder’s clerk inked into the front of each volume from 1834 on, plus the payroll books at the annex and the retirement ledger, which is the thorough one. There is no W.J.M. anywhere in Chastain County. Not on a payroll, not on a pension, not among the nineteen men and two women who ran that office between the wars. He exists in one place in the whole county: a margin, a curl, two sets of initials, on a chain of title that is otherwise clean.
And it is clean. That’s the part I want set down plainly. I ran the Hoyl stretch three more times from the original, line by line, and every conveyance is good. No gaps, no forged notary, no widow’s dower lurking under an alias. Taxes paid through last December. The buyer got forty honest acres and a pond with bass in it, and if the old hand under the vault floor was warning anybody about anything, I never found what. The mark asks for one thing only.
It asks to be made again.
The Last Hour
The recorder did me a kindness, or the scheduling did. Friday morning, eight to nine, the vault open for one hour past the public deadline, the contractor’s crates already stacked by the door. I could have certified from the film — risked the dropped leaves, begged the hour — or gone down and run the column once more, hand on paper, the way the work is actually done.
I took the kid. First-year paralegal, learning to trace, hands still soft. I stood him in front of the Hoyle column and put his finger on the top line the way my first boss had put mine, and he walked it down slow, saying the entries out loud — Hoyl to Hoyl, 1911 — and at the end of the line his finger rose, curved, and set down. He laughed and said sorry, and did it again at 1928.
I ran it last. The curl came before the first word. Fine. At nine the contractor sealed the room, and the crates went to Columbus, and the county got its terminals.
The closing held at 10:40. No one was harmed; the land is good. In the firm’s abstract book, beside the Hoyle entry, in pencil, with the lightest hand I own, I set the mark. Not because anything is wrong with the title. Because a traced column with no mark on it reads, to my hand now, like a sentence left unfinished — and if a hand ever traces that page the way I was taught, I know which stroke it will be waiting to learn.
In September, at the new counter, over a printout for an unrelated parcel the old hand never touched, my pencil made the first quarter of a loop I have never seen anywhere.
I let it finish. Then I entered the number, filed the sheet, and kept the pencil.
