The Check-In Inventory
The flat came furnished because the purchase on our own place was dragging and the vendor wanted proof of a short-term tenant, not comfort: a gas hob with one dead ring, a wardrobe that smelled of the previous tenant’s ironing, a pine table with four chairs arranged around it in a way that suggested nobody had ever eaten there.
Item 34 on the inventory read:
- Dining table, pine, and chairs (4) — good general condition.
The clerk ticked it twice, once on her copy and once on ours, and I countersigned at the kitchen counter while Jon held the door for the movers. I do this for a living — third-party motor claims, eleven years, the reconciliation of what people swear happened against what the documents agree to say — so I read every line before signing. Four chairs. £950 deposit, protected with the scheme, refundable in full if we handed the flat back as found.
We needed every pound of it. Completion was set for March and the removals firm wanted cash on the day.
Nine months of ordinary tenancy. Jon worked nights at the depot and slept till noon; I left for the office at seven and filed other people’s disputes. We ate at the pine table maybe four times. In February I opened the scheme’s check-out pack and started the photographic evidence they ask for, room by room, the way I’d advise a policyholder to do it. Kitchen last. Table, hob, window, floor. Four chairs at the table.
Jon took the wide shot on his phone, because his camera was better than mine.
The photograph had five chairs in it.
Four of Five
He swore the phone hadn’t stitched anything. I made him take twelve more, from the hall doorway, from the window, one from directly above with me standing on the table like a lunatic. Twelve photographs, five chairs, the fifth pulled up close to the table on the north side with its back to the window, as though someone had got up from it mid-meal.
We didn’t own a fifth chair. That’s the sentence I kept arriving at, and it’s still the true one.
The rational explanations came easily, the way they do at the start. The agency would sort it. I emailed the check-in inventory through and asked them to confirm item 34 as a clerical baseline. Their PDF came back the next morning.
- Dining table, pine, and chairs (5) — good general condition.
I fetched our countersigned copy from the warranty tin. Ours said four. Same clerk, same tick marks, same date, my signature on both versions of the page. I photographed the photocopy at my desk and sent it, and the office manager rang me back within the hour, apologetic, and said their system held only one version — the five — and had I perhaps printed mine from a draft? I work with drafts for a living. I know what a draft looks like.
The viewing sheet came next, because Jon dug out his emails to check we hadn’t imagined the flat smaller than it was. 12 June, furnished viewing, the agent’s tick-list: table & 4 chairs. Four, in his inbox, in writing, from the agent herself. And beneath it, in the notes field she had filled at 14:10 that afternoon, parking for 1, chairs x5 confirmed with landlord.
Every document we pulled agreed with every other document, except the ones that agreed with us, and each new document weighed a little more than the last.
Item 34
Here is where I made it worse, and I want to be exact about the mechanics, because the mechanism is all I ever had.
The scheme’s adjudication runs on evidence, so I gave them evidence. I re-photographed the kitchen with the date stamp on. I submitted Jon’s June email, our countersigned inventory, a signed statement from the mover who had carried the furniture in on a two-wheel trolley and remembered the count, because four chairs is an awkward load and five is worse. The adjudicator acknowledged receipt in nine working days.
Her bundle came back with the agency’s inventory, the landlord’s original purchase invoice from 2011 — dining set, table + 6 chairs — and the check-out photographs her own inspector had taken at the flat on 26 February. In those, five chairs stood around the table. The fifth had a scorch on the seat, a cigarette burn or a pan scald, and the adjudicator proposed a deduction of £140 for the damage: itemised, referenced, photographed at three exposures.
I went home and stood in my kitchen. Four chairs. I counted them the way you count your own fingers, not trusting the arithmetic and trusting nothing else either. Jon came in at noon from nights, looked at the table, and asked why I’d arranged them all bunched to one side when the fifth was getting repaired.
No chair had gone anywhere for repair. But he could no longer picture the room with four in it, and that was the part no form captured — that the paperwork was patient, and consistent, and mine was one signature against a system that never contradicts itself twice.
Check-Out
We signed. Completion was the following Tuesday and the deposit release held the removals to it, and £950 minus £140 still covered the men and the van. The adjudicator closed the file with the fifth chair photographed, itemised and paid for, and the inspector’s report listed it in situ, seat damage consistent with contact heat, and I initialled every page in blue biro because my hand still knew how to do that while the rest of me stood somewhere else.
The flat went back with five chairs in it. On the last morning I wiped all five down for the handover, and I could not have said which four of them I had wiped the year before, or on which day the fifth had become one I wiped.
Jon remembers five now, and he remembers the scorch. He remembers knocking the chair against the radiator the winter we ran the heater in the kitchen, and he can describe the mark — an oval, brown at the rim — well enough that I’ve stopped correcting him in front of people. His version has a history in it. Mine has a photocopy.
It’s in the warranty tin at the new house: our countersigned copy, item 34 in my own ink, dining table, pine, and chairs (4). No office will take it now. The scheme’s file is closed, the agency’s system holds the five, and the one document that agrees with me exists in a single copy I have decided not to lose.
